J3P Backtest - Edge Read Wide liquid universe (52 names)

James Three Plays (Pull-In / Trend / Backside) - ~12 trading days ending 2026-06-26 - 5-min bars - generated 2026-06-27 ET
Trades804 Total P&L (per $100 risk/trade)$-15,180 Win %44.5% Avg R-0.190

Verdict - where the edge is (and isn't)

Edge gate (Stage 4 hotkeys): only positive-expectancy cells (avg_R>0, adequate n) advance. Charts of every trade: execution charts →

By Playbook

playbooknwinstotal_pnlavg_Ravg_mfe_Ravg_mae_Rwin_pct
backside_scalp219$39.89+0.018+0.876-0.79642.9%
vwap_pull_in563252$-9,027.55-0.161+0.515-0.62744.8%
trend_trade22097$-6,192.27-0.282+0.783-0.81644.1%

By Playbook x Grade

playbookgradenwinstotal_pnlavg_Ravg_mfe_Ravg_mae_Rwin_pct
vwap_pull_inA33$95.52+0.319+0.628-0.852100.0%
trend_tradeA106$135.35+0.131+0.569-0.55960.0%
backside_scalpB219$39.89+0.018+0.876-0.79642.9%
vwap_pull_in-542244$-8,234.65-0.153+0.522-0.61945.0%
trend_tradeB3820$-668.32-0.178+0.482-0.54352.6%
trend_tradeC17271$-5,659.30-0.329+0.862-0.89141.3%
vwap_pull_inC104$-463.31-0.461+0.367-0.77840.0%
vwap_pull_inB81$-425.11-0.538+0.207-0.90812.5%

By Playbook x VCET Regime (🔎 click a row to see those trades in the viewer)

playbookvcet_statenwinstotal_pnlavg_Ravg_mfe_Ravg_mae_Rwin_pct
backside_scalp 🔎TREND_DOWN11$26.93+0.269+0.310-0.772100.0%
backside_scalp 🔎TREND_UP62$88.02+0.147+0.944-0.94633.3%
backside_scalp 🔎ROTATION136$26.47+0.021+0.930-0.69146.2%
vwap_pull_in 🔎TREND_DOWN3117$-100.17-0.030+0.609-0.50454.8%
vwap_pull_in 🔎TREND_UP8040$-822.75-0.107+0.501-0.60250.0%
vwap_pull_in 🔎COMPRESSION73$-123.35-0.173+0.354-0.46742.9%
vwap_pull_in 🔎ROTATION425185$-7,425.14-0.175+0.517-0.64243.5%
vwap_pull_in 🔎FAILED_EXPANSION_TENTATIVE63$-126.61-0.217+0.654-0.89150.0%
trend_trade 🔎TREND_UP22097$-6,192.27-0.282+0.783-0.81644.1%
vwap_pull_in 🔎MEAN_REVERSION103$-292.77-0.294+0.351-0.53530.0%
vwap_pull_in 🔎FAILED_EXPANSION_CONFIRMED41$-136.76-0.345+0.340-0.55325.0%
backside_scalp 🔎MEAN_REVERSION10$-101.53-1.042+0.342-1.2760.0%

By Playbook x Tier

playbooktiernwinstotal_pnlavg_Ravg_mfe_Ravg_mae_Rwin_pct
backside_scalpext219$39.89+0.018+0.876-0.79642.9%
vwap_pull_inband1295137$-3,908.19-0.134+0.457-0.58146.4%
vwap_pull_inband319279$-3,653.30-0.190+0.608-0.68341.1%
vwap_pull_inband27636$-1,466.06-0.194+0.509-0.66147.4%
trend_trade1st_dev22097$-6,192.27-0.282+0.783-0.81644.1%

Full edge gate - Playbook x Grade x Tier x Regime (🔎 click to drill into the trades)

playbookgradetiervcet_statenwinstotal_pnlavg_Ravg_mfe_Ravg_mae_Rwin_pct
vwap_pull_in 🔎-band2TREND_DOWN44$188.33+0.476+0.910-0.292100.0%
vwap_pull_in 🔎Cband1COMPRESSION11$40.29+0.413+0.650-0.152100.0%
vwap_pull_in 🔎Aband3ROTATION22$71.48+0.359+0.572-0.876100.0%
backside_scalp 🔎BextTREND_DOWN11$26.93+0.269+0.310-0.772100.0%
vwap_pull_in 🔎Aband3TREND_UP11$24.04+0.239+0.741-0.804100.0%
vwap_pull_in 🔎-band2TREND_UP75$107.69+0.151+0.648-0.60271.4%
backside_scalp 🔎BextTREND_UP62$88.02+0.147+0.944-0.94633.3%
trend_trade 🔎A1st_devTREND_UP106$135.35+0.131+0.569-0.55960.0%
vwap_pull_in 🔎-band1FAILED_EXPANSION_TENTATIVE32$25.38+0.073+0.834-0.81666.7%
backside_scalp 🔎BextROTATION136$26.47+0.021+0.930-0.69146.2%
vwap_pull_in 🔎-band3TREND_DOWN21$-10.94-0.056+0.571-0.16350.0%
vwap_pull_in 🔎-band1TREND_UP5129$-295.52-0.063+0.565-0.57056.9%
vwap_pull_in 🔎-band1MEAN_REVERSION42$-39.29-0.099+0.147-0.54550.0%
vwap_pull_in 🔎-band1TREND_DOWN2512$-277.56-0.109+0.564-0.56548.0%
vwap_pull_in 🔎-band1ROTATION19385$-2,586.86-0.135+0.425-0.57444.0%
vwap_pull_in 🔎-band3TREND_UP123$-206.75-0.175+0.320-0.53325.0%
trend_trade 🔎B1st_devTREND_UP3820$-668.32-0.178+0.482-0.54352.6%
vwap_pull_in 🔎-band3ROTATION17071$-3,387.98-0.199+0.631-0.70541.8%
vwap_pull_in 🔎-band2ROTATION5325$-1,148.84-0.218+0.511-0.65747.2%
vwap_pull_in 🔎-band2FAILED_EXPANSION_TENTATIVE21$-48.43-0.240+0.653-0.78050.0%
vwap_pull_in 🔎-band1COMPRESSION62$-163.64-0.271+0.305-0.52033.3%
vwap_pull_in 🔎-band3MEAN_REVERSION51$-143.15-0.288+0.526-0.42120.0%
vwap_pull_in 🔎-band2FAILED_EXPANSION_CONFIRMED10$-29.37-0.289+0.201-0.1140.0%
trend_trade 🔎C1st_devTREND_UP17271$-5,659.30-0.329+0.862-0.89141.3%
vwap_pull_in 🔎-band1FAILED_EXPANSION_CONFIRMED31$-107.39-0.364+0.386-0.70033.3%
vwap_pull_in 🔎Bband2TREND_UP30$-117.83-0.394+0.114-0.8170.0%
vwap_pull_in 🔎Bband2ROTATION41$-203.72-0.519+0.301-0.86925.0%
vwap_pull_in 🔎Cband1ROTATION31$-169.22-0.544+0.412-0.81033.3%
vwap_pull_in 🔎Cband1TREND_UP62$-334.38-0.565+0.297-0.86633.3%
backside_scalp 🔎BextMEAN_REVERSION10$-101.53-1.042+0.342-1.2760.0%
vwap_pull_in 🔎Bband2FAILED_EXPANSION_TENTATIVE10$-103.56-1.043+0.114-1.3380.0%
vwap_pull_in 🔎-band2MEAN_REVERSION10$-110.33-1.104+0.287-1.0690.0%

Walk-forward — in-sample vs out-of-sample (chronological 70/30: IS < 2026-06-23 ≤ OOS)

playbookIS nIS avg_ROOS nOOS avg_R
backside_scalp17-0.1004+0.518
trend_trade137-0.28483-0.279
vwap_pull_in359-0.127204-0.221
A play with real edge should stay positive out-of-sample. Read the OOS avg_R column: a play that flips negative (or stays negative) across the split is not a stable edge — it isn't something to automate.

Method & caveats

Symbols: AAPL, ABNB, ADBE, AMAT, AMD, AMZN, ASML, AVGO, COIN, CRM, CRWD, CVNA, DELL, DIA, DKNG, GOOGL, HOOD, INTC, IWM, LRCX, MARA, META, MSFT, MSTR, MU, NET, NFLX, NVDA, ON, ORCL, PANW, PLTR, QCOM, QQQ, RIOT, RIVN, ROKU, SHOP, SMCI, SMH, SNAP, SNOW, SOFI, SOXL, SPY, SQQQ, TQQQ, TSLA, TXN, UBER, XLE, XLF. Bars: real 1-min karb/kti -> 5-min. Regime: VCET v1.1 engine (vcet_state) per session. Plays mirror J3P_v2.2_SIP_Webhook.pine. Next-bar-open fills, conservative slippage, 0.5c/sh commission, constant $100 risk/trade sizing (so names of any price are comparable; total P&L = "if you risked $100/trade"). R = net P&L / initial risk. RTH 09:30-15:55 ET, force-flat 15:45. Single-digit-n cells are directional only. Roadmap: plan.