π§© What makes a stock pay β long vs short
The nuances that made the setups win, split by direction. From real setups over 90 days, and every rule held in a fresh out-of-sample test.
π‘ Both sides: catch the move that's still coming, not one that already happened.
But longs and shorts want different weather β see below.
π LONG plays baseline +0.27R Β· 3,163 setups
π pays MORE
- quiet open (small gap)pays ~2Γ
- wild day 8%+pays ~2Γ
π pays LESS
- gapped DOWNpays ~ΒΌ
- gapped up BIG 5%+pays ~half
- already ripped 12%+pays ~ΒΌ
- way extended 12%+pays ~half
- normal day 4-8%pays ~half
π SHORT plays baseline +0.16R Β· 357 setups
π pays MORE
- quiet open (small gap)pays ~2Γ
- normal day 4-8%pays extra
π pays LESS
- was flatpays ~ΒΌ
- wild day 8%+pays ~ΒΌ
The key difference: LONGS want a wild day (lots of movement to ride up), SHORTS want a steady, normal day (a wild day can squeeze you). Both like a quiet open (not gapped), and both get hurt chasing a stock that already made its move. The cockpit applies these to each stock automatically β this page is just the "why."
(Short sample is smaller than long, so treat the short rules as a lighter lean.)