The vwap-pull-in -> trend bucket is a MIXED bucket — and within the classifiable subset, the dollar edge comes from rotation scalps, NOT trend conversions.
Of 6 classifiable trades (bars + rules fit): 1 true Pull-In → Trend conversion (JOBY 5/28, +$12.45), 3 VWAP rotation scalps (DAL 5/26, 5/27, 5/28; net +$96), 2 wrong-side escapes that profited anyway (JOBY 5/29 +$0.70, HL 6/3 +$12.25).
Even when the rule fits cleanly, only 1 of 6 trades (16.7%) is mechanically what the slug name claims. The bucket's profit pattern is dominated by something other than trend conversion.
| Mechanism | n | Total P&L | Win rate | % of classifiable P&L |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| vwap_rotation_scalp | 3 | +$96.34 | 3/3 (100%) | 75.5% |
| true_pull_in_to_trend | 1 | +$12.45 | 1/1 (100%) | 9.8% |
| wrong_side_escape | 2 | +$12.95 | 2/2 (100%) | 10.2% |
| insufficient_data (NO_BAR) | 6 | +$235.24 | 6/6 | — |
| insufficient_data (trend-continuation) | 3 | +$10.69 | 2/3 | — |
| TOTAL | 15 | +$367.67 | 14/15 (93%) |
| Trade | Side | Net P&L | Gap % | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AAOI 4/10 10:09 | LONG | +$136.29 | +4.2% | Largest winner in dataset; mechanism unknown |
| CAR 4/16 10:06 | SHORT | +$53.76 | −0.7% | Only SHORT in the bucket |
| WULF 4/13 09:37 | LONG | +$18.48 | −1.7% | |
| CRWV 4/13 10:17 | LONG | +$9.21 | +7.4% | |
| RGTI 4/15 10:07 | LONG | +$8.92 | +9.7% | |
| SPY 5/1 10:43 | LONG | +$8.58 | −0.9% |
These predate the kti 14-day window. Cannot classify mechanism. They represent 64% of the bucket's total P&L ($235 / $368) — any conclusion about the bucket's mechanism is necessarily limited by the historical-bar gap.
| Trade | Net P&L | Entry state | Trajectory | Observation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| LUNR 5/26 09:49 LONG | −$11.76 | TREND_UP | TREND_UP throughout, slope decelerating (+70° → +18°) | Bucket's only LOSER. Entered already-extended in a fading trend. Priority 3 shouldn't have produced this for a loser; came via Phase 2 backfill from manual trader label. |
| BB 5/28 11:56 LONG | +$18.40 | TREND_UP | TREND_UP whole window, slope flat (+10° → +4°), bw flat at 8.7 | Entered into established TREND_UP slowly decelerating — trend continuation entry, not a conversion |
| INTC 6/2 10:44 LONG | +$4.05 | TREND_UP | TREND_UP whole window, slope mildly accelerating (+1.2° → +5°) | Similar — trend continuation, not Pull-In |
Sub-B reveals a category not in rules A/B/C: trades where entry state was already TREND_* in trade direction. That's not a Pull-In conversion — it's a trend continuation entry. The classifier's "entry near VWAP" condition does NOT mean "state was ROTATION/COMPRESSION." Trades can enter near the rolling VWAP price while VCET is already calling TREND_UP/DOWN. The classifier is blind to state at entry.
RVOL 1.59 · gap +0.74% · ATR +0.11 · MTF 62 · no catalyst
| t | state | slope° | bw% | exp | close |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| −5 | ROTATION | +1.61 | 1.54 | 20 | 11.43 |
| 0 | ROTATION | +17.99 | 2.98 | 75 | 11.59 |
| +5 | ROTATION | +31.37 | 5.03 | 75 | 11.76 |
| +10 | ROTATION | +42.92 | 6.16 | 75 | 11.87 |
| +15 | TREND_UP | +49.06 | 6.42 | 35 | 11.83 |
| +25 | TREND_UP | +44.38 | 6.72 | 20 | 11.98 |
Evidence: bw(+5)=5.03 ≥ 1.5 × bw(0)=2.98 ✓ · expansion_score(+5)=75 ≥ 50 ✓ · Δslope(+5) = +13.4° ≥ +5° ✓ · state=TREND_UP at +15min ✓ (4 of 5 sub-checks → HIGH).
Verdict: Textbook ROTATION → TREND_UP conversion in 15 minutes. Bands doubled, slope exploded, state transitioned cleanly. This IS what the slug name claims.
RVOL 0.73 · gap −1.31% · ATR −0.39 · MTF 83 · no catalyst
| t | state | slope° | bw% | exp | close |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| −5 | ROTATION | −0.39 | 1.49 | 0 | 78.32 |
| 0 | ROTATION | −0.35 | 1.49 | 0 | 78.42 |
| +5 | ROTATION | −0.35 | 1.49 | 15 | 78.54 |
| +10 | ROTATION | −0.34 | 1.49 | 0 | 78.53 |
| +15 | ROTATION | −0.29 | 1.48 | 0 | 78.50 |
| +25 | ROTATION | −0.20 | 1.48 | 0 | 78.52 |
Verdict: Pure TD VWAP rotation. Slope ≈ 0 throughout, bands flat at 1.49, no expansion ever fired. Trade made +$68 from rotating around VWAP — not from trend.
RVOL 1.31 · gap −5.35% · ATR −1.62 · MTF 82 · no catalyst
| t | state | slope° | bw% | exp | close |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| −5 | ROTATION | −1.15 | 2.82 | 35 | 81.73 |
| 0 | ROTATION | −1.34 | 2.86 | 15 | 81.71 |
| +5 | ROTATION | −1.63 | 2.92 | 35 | 81.49 |
| +10 | ROTATION | −1.76 | 2.97 | 15 | 81.46 |
| +15 | ROTATION | −1.92 | 3.01 | 15 | 81.50 |
| +25 | ROTATION | −1.40 | 3.05 | 0 | 81.56 |
Verdict: Counter-trend buy on −5.35% gap-down. Stayed in ROTATION 25 min. Price went AGAINST the LONG entry (81.71 → 81.56). +$22 was tight sizing / fast scratch / partial scale near entry.
RVOL 0.94 · gap −8.14% · ATR −2.50 · MTF 74 · no catalyst
| t | state | slope° | bw% | exp | close |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| −5 | ROTATION | +0.21 | 2.84 | 15 | 81.97 |
| 0 | ROTATION | +0.27 | 2.82 | 35 | 81.93 |
| +5 | ROTATION | +0.20 | 2.81 | 0 | 81.89 |
| +10 | ROTATION | +0.20 | 2.79 | 0 | 81.95 |
| +15 | ROTATION | +0.17 | 2.78 | 0 | 81.88 |
| +25 | ROTATION | +0.11 | 2.75 | 0 | 82.01 |
Verdict: Compression scalp. Bands CONTRACTING (2.84 → 2.75), slope flat near 0, expansion never fired. Modest +$0.08 drift over 25 min. Compression existed but never resolved into expansion.
RVOL 1.76 · gap −5.61% · ATR −0.88 · MTF 22 (weak) · no catalyst
| t | state | slope° | bw% | exp | close |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| −5 | ROTATION | −3.94 | 2.05 | 75 | 12.12 |
| 0 | ROTATION | −36.59 | 5.54 | 75 | 11.92 |
| +5 | TREND_DOWN | −52.74 | 7.02 | 75 | 11.73 |
| +10 | TREND_DOWN | −62.22 | 7.59 | 35 | 11.74 |
| +15 | TREND_DOWN | −66.91 | 7.51 | 35 | 11.77 |
| +25 | TREND_DOWN | −37.09 | 7.24 | 20 | 11.78 |
Verdict: LONG into a TREND_DOWN crash. Price fell 11.92 → 11.73 in first 5 min (−1.6%). The +$0.70 P&L is noise — likely instant scratch or tiny share count. VCET was reading the down-trend correctly.
RVOL 0.99 · gap −4.69% · MTF −57 (weak) · no catalyst
| t | state | slope° | bw% | exp |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| −5 | TREND_DOWN | −4.94 | 3.59 | 0 |
| 0 | TREND_DOWN | −3.16 | 3.50 | 0 |
| +5 | TREND_DOWN | −2.04 | 3.37 | 20 |
| +10 | TREND_DOWN | −1.22 | 3.31 | 0 |
| +15 | TREND_DOWN | +0.69 | 3.29 | 0 |
| +25 | TREND_DOWN | +2.49 | 3.30 | 15 |
Important nuance: Slope was DECELERATING through the snap window (−4.94° → +2.49°). Slope CROSSED ZERO around +15min. Mechanically this is closer to a reversal-from-down entry — the down-trend was rolling over while VCET's state lagged (state-sticky behavior). Rule C called wrong_side_escape (state-based and technically correct); trader's intent looks like early reversal entry. MTF at −57 (weak) consistent with a fading trend.
Verdict: Rule says wrong_side_escape HIGH; mechanically defensible as reversal-attempt. Profited because slope crossover happened within the management window.
| Trade | Proposed mechanism | Confidence | Evidence | P&L |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AAOI 4/10 LONG | insufficient_data | — | NO_BAR (pre-kti) | +$136.29 |
| WULF 4/13 LONG | insufficient_data | — | NO_BAR | +$18.48 |
| CRWV 4/13 LONG | insufficient_data | — | NO_BAR | +$9.21 |
| RGTI 4/15 LONG | insufficient_data | — | NO_BAR | +$8.92 |
| CAR 4/16 SHORT | insufficient_data | — | NO_BAR | +$53.76 |
| SPY 5/1 LONG | insufficient_data | — | NO_BAR | +$8.58 |
| LUNR 5/26 LONG | insufficient_data | — | Entry TREND_UP (already trending); no rule fits | −$11.76 |
| DAL 5/26 13:56 LONG | vwap_rotation_scalp | HIGH | ROTATION 25min, slope ≈ 0, bw 1.49 flat | +$68.25 |
| DAL 5/27 13:56 LONG | vwap_rotation_scalp | HIGH | ROTATION 25min, slope −1.34 → −1.40, bw 2.86 → 3.05 | +$22.50 |
| JOBY 5/28 09:31 LONG | true_pull_in_to_trend | HIGH | bw 2.98 → 6.42, slope +1.6° → +49°, state → TREND_UP @ +15 | +$12.45 |
| BB 5/28 11:56 LONG | insufficient_data | — | Entry already TREND_UP; trend continuation entry | +$18.40 |
| DAL 5/28 13:56 LONG | vwap_rotation_scalp | HIGH | ROTATION + compression (comp=30), bw 2.84 → 2.75 | +$5.59 |
| JOBY 5/29 09:31 LONG | wrong_side_escape | HIGH | LONG into TREND_DOWN; slope −3.9° → −52.7°; barely escaped | +$0.70 |
| INTC 6/2 LONG | insufficient_data | — | Entry already TREND_UP; trend continuation entry | +$4.05 |
| HL 6/3 LONG | wrong_side_escape | HIGH | LONG into TREND_DOWN, slope decelerating (reversal interpretation also defensible) | +$12.25 |
vwap-pull-in -> trend bucket mostly...C — MIXED bucket.
Of 15 trades: 1 true conversion (6.7%, 3.4% of $) · 3 rotation scalps (20%, 26.2% of $) · 2 wrong-side escapes (13.3%, 3.5% of $) · 3 trend-continuation entries (20%, 2.9% of $; includes the bucket's only loser) · 6 unclassifiable due to bar history (40%, 64% of $).
The bucket's profitability is real, but the dollar edge inside the classifiable subset is driven by rotation scalps, NOT by trend conversion. The 1 confirmed conversion made only $12.45 — less than 4% of total dollar edge.
vwap-pull-in -> trend remain a canonical slug for now?YES — with a documented mechanism caveat (already added 2026-06-04 to Quality Gate, Cheatsheet, MGP block).
Keep it because: it IS a profitable pattern (+$367, 93% win rate); the slug is wired into Phase 2 backfill (297 rows), workflow docs, performance report; removing/renaming mid-stride would break dashboards.
Needs the caveat because: the name overstates the trend-conversion mechanism by ~5× in the classifiable subset.
mechanism_slug later?YES — this audit provides the empirical basis.
The 6 classifiable trades show distinct mechanism signatures detectable from VCET trajectory at 5-min granularity, with different P&L profiles (rotation +$32 avg, true conversion +$12 avg, wrong-side +$6 avg), implying different management styles.
Sequencing: wait for ~15-25 more classifiable trades (3-6 months) before committing schema. Today's n=6 is too small.
YES — done. Caveat added 2026-06-04 to Quality Gate, Cheatsheet, and MGP block. Mechanism-aware management rule section also added to all three.
Stop-rule suggestion: if 5 min post-entry the band hasn't expanded and slope hasn't accelerated, treat as rotation scalp regardless of slug. Manage to band. The breakout isn't coming.
trend_continuation_entry) likely belongs in the catalog.mechanism_slug column added · No gen_scorecard.py editsmain.user_strategies changes/system/PULL_IN_TO_TREND_MECHANISM_AUDIT.htmlvcet/python/pi_trend_mechanism_audit.pyPhase board unchanged.