The gate concept improves expectancy — but almost entirely through the RED exclusion (driven by gap > 1.5%) and the post-entry checkpoints, not through the RVOL thresholds. Bucketed RVOL does not separate winners from losers (the calmest <1.0 bucket is the worst). Instrument type is a stronger separator than RVOL. Promote the proven parts in stages; rework the RVOL axis first.
|gap| > 1.5% holds −$341.93 at 24.1% win (n=54), and it's 100% populated. Both large gap-up and large gap-down lose.<1.0 bucket is the worst (−$320.62). The old "high RVOL = chase = loss" story was driven by a few outliers (loser-mean 4.01), not by the bulk of trades.The original framing was "calm tape good, hot tape bad." The bucketed data says the enemy is more specific: big gaps (>1.5%), crypto-proxy/small-cap names, and uncut fades — not high RVOL. High-RVOL (>2.5) trades lost only −$58 on n=13; the calmest (<1.0) trades lost −$320. Keep the gate's spirit; change which dials it turns.
RVOL ≥ 1.0 floor for GREEN — it incidentally excludes the losing <1.0 bucket, but it's confounded with instrument type. working_rule_needs_backtest.|gap| < 1.5% — weak separation (yellow ≥ green here).RVOL populated on 108/132 (82%). Buckets are non-monotonic — note the <1.0 row.
| RVOL bucket | n | Win % | Total P&L | Avg/trade | Avg win | Avg loss |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| < 1.0 (calmest) | 53 | 32.1% | −$320.62 | −$6.05 | +$18.21 | −$17.51 |
| 1.0–1.5 (green) | 26 | 34.6% | −$23.80 | −$0.92 | +$17.26 | −$10.54 |
| 1.5–2.5 (yellow) | 16 | 43.8% | +$14.27 | +$0.89 | +$18.10 | −$12.49 |
| > 2.5 (red) | 13 | 30.8% | −$58.20 | −$4.48 | +$18.39 | −$14.64 |
| NA (not populated) | 24 | 41.7% | +$90.22 | +$3.76 | +$26.14 | −$12.23 |
Read: the gate predicts <1.0 should be safest and >2.5 worst. The data shows the opposite at the low end. RVOL does not separate as designed — likely confounded by instrument type (low-RVOL crypto-proxies sit in <1.0).
Gap populated on 132/132 (100%). Bucketed by |gap| to match the gate.
| |Gap| bucket | n | Win % | Total P&L | Avg/trade |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| < 0.5% (green) | 40 | 40.0% | −$36.40 | −$0.91 |
| 0.5–1.5% (yellow) | 38 | 47.4% | +$80.20 | +$2.11 |
| > 1.5% (red) | 54 | 24.1% | −$341.93 | −$6.33 |
| Direction | n | Win % | Total P&L |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gap up > +1.5% | 34 | 26.5% | −$200.09 |
| Gap down < −1.5% | 20 | 20.0% | −$141.84 |
Read: the |gap| > 1.5% RED rule is the cleanest, most reliable filter in the whole gate. The green/yellow split below 1.5% does NOT separate (yellow actually beat green). Gap's value is the RED line, not the gradation.
| State at window | 3 min | 5 min | 10 min | 15 min |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fade — win % | 6.7% (n30) | 9.4% (n32) | 10.3% (n39) | 17.5% (n40) |
| Flat rotation — win % | 44.2% | 35.0% | 31.2% | 34.6% |
| Early expansion — win % | 62.5% (n8) | 72.7% (n11) | 70.6% (n17) | 77.8% (n18) |
| Early-exp % reached next band | 100% | 81.8% | 100% | 100% |
Q3 read: a fade at 3 minutes wins 6.7% — the "respect the 3-minute failure" rule is decisively supported and should be a HARD rule. Q4 read: early expansion confirmed by 10–15 min wins ~70–78% and reaches the next band; trend-hold should only be allowed after this. Plain-PI vs vwap-pull-in → trend: PI→Trend trades are favorable at 5/15 min ~73% (early-expansion ~47–60%) vs plain-PI ~34% favorable / ~8–14% expansion — the conversion shows up fast.
| Sym | n | Win % | P&L |
|---|---|---|---|
| IBIT robust | 10 | 30% | −$185.51 |
| CVX robust | 5 | 20% | −$44.63 |
| AMD tiny | 3 | 0% | −$69.65 |
| ETHU tiny | 3 | 0% | −$69.35 |
| RGTI tiny | 3 | 0% | −$38.98 |
| META | 9 | 55.6% | −$19.13 |
| Sym | n | Win % | P&L |
|---|---|---|---|
| MSFT | 4 | 100% | +$133.54 |
| AMZN | 9 | 44.4% | +$43.93 |
| TSLA | 6 | 66.7% | +$43.39 |
| GOOGL | 5 | 60% | +$32.67 |
Read: only IBIT (n=10) and CVX (n=5) are robust-sample losers. AMD/ETHU/RGTI are 0% but n=3 — warnings, not a proven blacklist. Don't hard-code the tiny-sample names.
| Instrument type | n | Win % | Total P&L | Avg/trade |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Megacap tech | 51 | 51.0% | +$151.91 | +$2.98 |
| ETF / crypto proxy | 27 | 40.7% | −$232.26 | −$8.60 |
| Small-cap / high-beta / other | 54 | 18.5% | −$217.78 | −$4.03 |
Read: the cleanest single separator after gap. Plain Pull-In is a megacap-tech play. Classification is heuristic (symbol→type map) and cells are moderate-n, so direction is proven, exact thresholds are working.
Old generic plain Pull-In: n=132, −$298.13, 35.6% win. Partitioned by the combined RVOL+gap gate:
| Gate bucket | n | Win % | Total P&L | Avg/trade |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| GREEN (rvol 1.0–1.5 & |gap|<0.5) | 10 | 30.0% | +$41.38 | +$4.14 |
| "green" but rvol <1.0 & calm gap | 17 | 41.2% | −$229.31 | −$13.49 |
| YELLOW | 32 | 50.0% | +$124.45 | +$3.89 |
| RED | 59 | 25.4% | −$356.72 | −$6.05 |
| Ungradable (rvol NA) | 14 | 42.9% | +$122.07 | +$8.72 |
Read: the gate works by isolating RED (−$356.72) — pass it and the book flips to ~+$59. YELLOW was net positive, so half-sizing it would have cut profit (−$62), not reduced drawdown. The RVOL≥1.0 floor matters: the "very calm" <1.0 sub-bucket lost −$229. GREEN proper is positive but tiny (n=10).
| Mistake tag | Computable now? | Finding / missing field |
|---|---|---|
| traded_red_gate | YES | 59 trades / −$356.72 — explains the entire leak |
| chased_hot_tape | partial | overlaps red gate (same population here) |
| ignored_3min_failure | YES | fade at 3 min wins 6.7% — real and costly |
| held_rotation_like_trend | partial | needs intended_management_mode / planned_hold |
| oversized_yellow | NO | missing position_size_vs_plan |
| no_clear_invalidation | NO | missing pre_trade_invalidation_defined |
| good_execution | derived | none of the above + followed checkpoints |
Read: the tags DO explain the leak — primarily traded_red_gate / chased_hot_tape (−$356.72) and ignored_3min_failure. But 2 of 7 tags need fields that aren't logged yet.
REVISE, then promote in stages. Do not promote the gate as currently specified (the RVOL axis is wrong). After one confirmatory walk-forward pass, promote the proven parts; rework RVOL; defer the weak parts.
|gap| > 1.5% → RED (primary)|gap|>1.5% RED rule in vwap_pull_in_strategy_library_draft.json; keep validation_status: working_rule_needs_backtest on every threshold until the pass confirms.gate_color (gap-driven), setup_classification, gap_pct, NEW instrument_type, first_3min_result, first_10_15min_confirmation.traded_red_gate, chased_hot_tape, ignored_3min_failure.position_size_vs_plan (for oversized_yellow) and pre_trade_invalidation_defined (for no_clear_invalidation).gen_scorecard.py / _scientific_overlay.js edits until approved.gap_pct + instrument_type now (computable live, reliable). Do not lead with RVOL — 82% populated and doesn't separate.first_3min_result / first_10_15min_confirmation at the ticket — the proven post-entry checkpoints can't fire live without it.gap-RED / type-RED / clean rather than an RVOL-centric label.position_size_vs_plan, pre_trade_invalidation_defined, intended_management_mode — block 2–3 of the mistake tags.vwap-pull-in → trend n=15; GREEN-proper n=10; several symbol/type cells n<10; PI→Trend post-entry cells n=1–6.Z:\trading\dev\vwap-band-entry-surface\ (Liberator backfill, stage_b/stage_c).