"Chase / Extended works."
"Chase / Extended is a mixed residual label hiding better mechanisms."
Is chase-extended profitable because A (true chases work), B (real setups mislabeled), C (artifacts), or D (insufficient data)?
Answer: B + C, supported by D. A is rejected.
The bucket's surface +$198.28 hides: 9 mislabeled real-setup trades carrying +$333.28 of edge, one outsized pre-market NVDA outlier (+$199.07), hold-time and time-of-day skew, and a residual mass of 37 trades that net modestly negative.
9 trades (15.5% of the bucket) generate +$333.28 from mechanisms that aren't chase: 7 trend_trade candidates (MTF ≥ 80 in trade direction, +$255.30) and 2 event_driven candidates (catalyst-driven, +$77.98, 2/2 WR). The remaining 49 trades net −$135.00. The chase setup itself is NOT a working edge.
Trades matching the Quality Gate canonical chase definition (RVOL > 2.5 AND |gap| > 1.5%):
| Date | Symbol | Side | RVOL | Gap % | Net P&L |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-04-13 09:39 | IBIT | LONG | 3.84 | +2.4% | +$1.08 |
| 2026-06-04 10:08 | IBIT | LONG | 2.74 | +1.9% | −$5.40 |
| TOTAL — n=2 | −$4.32 | ||||
Both are IBIT, both LONG. 1W / 1L. The canonical chase mechanism is unprofitable in this sample — consistent with the Quality Gate's earlier read of chase-extended as "behavioral chase tag, not an edge."
| Date | Symbol | Side | MTF | RVOL | Gap % | P&L | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-05-04 09:32 | CRWV | LONG | 84 | 2.23 | +3.5% | +$26.05 | Clean trend confluence |
| 2026-05-04 09:35 | DXYZ | LONG | 103 | 2.62 | +2.9% | +$31.31 | Strong MTF |
| 2026-05-07 09:41 | DDOG | LONG | 90 | 7.23 | +32.3% | −$1.90 | Earnings-blowoff territory; barely scratched |
| 2026-05-11 09:33 | NVDA | LONG | 81 | 1.79 | +0.2% | +$33.32 | |
| 2026-05-29 09:25 | RGTI | LONG | 97 | 0.04 | −1.2% | −$23.20 | RVOL near zero — MTF up but tape dead |
| 2026-05-29 10:02 | MASK | LONG | 106 | 0.85 | +30.5% | −$9.35 | Crypto-name w/ huge gap; thin tape |
| 2026-06-02 05:58 | NVDA | LONG | 81 | 3.27 | +2.0% | +$199.07 | Pre-market — dominant outlier |
4 of 7 winners; +$199 comes from one pre-market NVDA; median per-trade is +$26.05. MTF ≥ 80 in direction is necessary but not sufficient — confidence stays MEDIUM (no intraday VWAP slope to confirm trend).
| Date | Symbol | Side | Catalyst | P&L |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-05-05 09:20 | INTC | LONG | minor_news | +$27.61 |
| 2026-05-06 09:32 | AAPL | LONG | minor_news | +$50.37 |
Both pre-9:45 open entries on named catalysts. Only HIGH-confidence calls in the audit — the catalyst fields are directly in the DB so the rule fires without proxy gaps.
| Proposed mechanism | n | Total P&L | Win rate | Confidence | % of bucket P&L |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| trend_trade (candidate) trend | 7 | +$255.30 | 4/7 (57%) | MEDIUM | 128.7% |
| event_driven (candidate) event | 2 | +$77.98 | 2/2 (100%) | HIGH | 39.3% |
| gap_fade (candidate) | 7 | −$3.06 | 3/7 (43%) | MEDIUM | −1.5% |
| chase_extended (confirmed) true chase | 2 | −$4.32 | 1/2 (50%) | MEDIUM | −2.2% |
| level_breakout (candidate) | 2 | −$31.51 | 1/2 (50%) | MEDIUM | −15.9% |
| counter_trend_scalp (candidate) | 1 | −$22.43 | 0/1 (0%) | LOW (heuristic) | −11.3% |
| insufficient_data unclassifiable | 37 | −$73.68 | 22/37 (59%) | INSUFFICIENT | −37.2% |
| TOTAL | 58 | +$198.28 | 33/58 (57%) | 100.0% |
Confidence distribution: HIGH n=2 · MEDIUM n=18 · LOW n=1 · INSUFFICIENT n=37.
Trades held >60 min carry 132% of the bucket's net profit; sub-15min trades net −$65. The 10-12 ET entry window is the only consistent loser.
| Hold bucket | n | Total P&L | Win rate | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sub-5 min | 4 | −$45.90 | 0/4 (0%) | Quick-exit losers (H2 heuristic) |
| 5–15 min | 3 | −$18.97 | 1/3 (33%) | |
| 15–60 min | 8 | +$1.93 | 3/8 (38%) | Near break-even |
| Over 60 min | 43 | +$261.22 | 29/43 (67%) | All the profit lives here |
| Window | n | Total P&L | Win rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pre-market (< 09:00) | 9 | +$92.06 | 6/9 (67%) |
| Open 09:30–09:45 | 27 | +$58.75 | 15/27 (56%) |
| 09:45–10:00 | 7 | +$55.53 | 5/7 (71%) |
| 10:00–12:00 | 10 | −$54.96 | 3/10 (30%) |
| 12:00–14:00 | 3 | +$39.62 | 3/3 (100%) |
| After 14:00 | 2 | +$7.28 | 1/2 (50%) |
Same Quality Gate finding as the plain Pull-In bucket: crypto-adjacent leveraged products do not behave like clean-tape setups, regardless of slug. ETHU (−$60), IBIT (−$47), MASK (−$9) = −$116 across 10 trades.
NVDA 2026-06-02 05:58 LONG, MTF=81, RVOL=3.27, gap=+2.0%, P&L = +$199.07.
This single pre-market entry accounts for 100.4% of the bucket's net +$198.28. Without it, the bucket nets −$0.79. The audit classifies it as a trend_trade candidate (strong MTF + matching direction), but its real mechanism (pre-market positioning on overnight strength? earnings catalyst? insider news? trend continuation?) is not determinable from the DB alone — and is mechanistically distinct from the "chase" framing the slug implies.
Implication: any aggregate read of the chase-extended bucket needs to be reported with and without NVDA 6/2 to be honest.
37 of 58 trades get insufficient_data because no candidate rule fires from main.trade_context fields. They need:
intraday_vwap_distance_at_entryvwap_band_width_pctvwap_slope_at_entrycandle_structure_HH_HLintraday_range_positionUntil these are in the DB, this audit is a partial picture. The Priority 5 chase-extended residual assignment honestly stands for these 37 trades, but their underlying mechanism is unknown.
Within the 37, top winners and losers:
22 winners / 15 losers within the 37 — modest positive raw rate, fat-tailed by the few large losers.
gen_scorecard.py Priority 5 should NOT absorb trades that meet a strong P5_catalyst or P6_trend_confluence rule.main.trade_context before any further reclassification work. Without it, 64% of this bucket is unclassifiable — and that's the structural blocker behind every MEDIUM ceiling in this audit.vwap-pull-in -> trend, chase-extended is an outcome-based residual label. Renaming or splitting it without VWAP geometry would be premature.gen_scorecard.py edits · no classifier logic changesmain.user_strategies / canonical taxonomy changes/system/vcet/python/Phase board unchanged.